And SNW and Silo seasons 2

This commit is contained in:
Shadowfacts 2025-02-12 16:11:09 -05:00
parent 717c661c75
commit bb7fa84e26
2 changed files with 193 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@ -90,3 +90,82 @@ Oh no jules you shouldnt have told him about the door
This show was fantastically well done, I eagerly await the next season. In the meantime, I think I'm going to reread the books.
All of the acting was good, and Rebecca Ferguson in particular was great. The writing and adaptation from the book was good (I think, it's been ages since I read the books). It was not action-packed, but it moved along at a fairly steady clip. The visuals were good, and the soundtrack was fantastic. There is, at this moment, not a thing I would change about this season.
<!-- episode "S02E01" 2024-11-16 -->
they omitted the detail from the book about the rancid soup lol
I feel like much of that ordeal could have been avoided if she hadnt tied the rope right over the middle
I cannot tell which sounds are supposed to be diegetic or nondiegetic
Im fascinated why they seem to have made him a complete recluse not even able to leave IT; that is not the case in the book
this was a very good episode. we are so back
<!-- episode "S02E02" 2024-11-27 -->
I'm very curious about the judge. She seems to have completely replaced Lukas from the books
<!-- episode "S02E03" 2024-12-07 -->
realized I'm an episode behind
Rebecca Ferguson is great. i have few other thoughts, this was a solid episode
<!-- episode "S02E04" 2024-12-07 -->
I am fascinated to see what becomes of Lukas, he was way more important in the book
juliette underwater is no less terrifying here than in the book (though I think in the book, she at least had the foresight to bring a knife to cut the rope)
boy, bernard keeps becoming even more of a motherfucker
ah yes, Apple Vision Pro
<!-- episode "S02E05" 2024-12-16 -->
i guess it makes for better television, but didn't—in the book—they make mention of it being faster to travel along the inside edge of the stairs?
i imagine coming to a stop that abruptly at the end of the cable would leave you incredibly badly injured
also sims' wife is perplexing
<!-- episode "S02E06" 2024-12-30 -->
ah, so Lucas is starting to come into place
this was a solid episode, though I wish we'd seen more of juliet/solo
<!-- episode "S02E07" 2025-01-12 -->
a thought has occurred to me: what if salvador quinn's/bernard's/lukas's question is "why are the silos necessary." i hope that does not portend the showwrunners dropping or minimizing Shift
i am curious to see what happens with the other inhabitant(s) of silo 17. what it seems like they were hinting at with the axe and the arrow and the blood does not align with the book
<!-- episode "S02E08" 2025-01-15 -->
Sims is just tiresome at this point
Walker becoming an informant I just do not buy
So I guess the other people in 17 are the kids, just way older than in the book. The pacing of Juliette's plot line is also tiresome—it felt like nothing happened this whole episode
This whole episode was... underwhelming
<!-- episode "S02E09" 2025-01-16 -->
I honestly cannot tell whether Knox is onto the fact that Walker is being spied on
imagine never having heard music in your life and then hearing monster mash
Tim Robbins is very good
This was one of the best episodes of the season. But given that we're only just getting to the end of _Wool,_ I grow increasingly concerned that they're just going to cut out _Shift_ altogether
<!-- episode "S02E10" 2025-01-19 -->
there's no way walker's hand signals were that obvious in the last episode; surely we would have noticed that
how was that explosion big enough to be heard/felt in silo 17
i still do not understand what's going on with camille
SHIFT, BABYYYYYYY, LFG!!
<!-- episode "Season 2 Conclusion" 2025-01-19 -->
This season was once again very good. My only complaint was that, at times, the pacing felt a little slow. But the payoff was worth it.
Rebecca Ferguson and Tim Robbins continue to be really great. Steve Zahn is also a solid addition.
I am incredibly excited for season 3 to see how they do Shift.

View File

@ -146,3 +146,117 @@ It's hard to overstate how happy I am that monster of the week/self-contained ep
And in spite of that, there was still continuity and character development from episode to episode.
I have no notes. That was _fantastic_. I'm probably going to rewatch the whole season in a few weeks.
<!-- episode "S02E01" 2023-06-15 -->
lmao, spock looks terrified
So that would make it two times that Uhura's stolen the Enterprise? nice
I continue to oppose how hard they're trying to make the catchphrases a thing for literally everyone. Lower Decks can be meta about it but it's weird when other shows do it
Starship in a cave is very Prodigy of them
is that super-strength drug new or did it show up last season? I have no recollection of it
aww, Spock you big softie
So Pike was there at the beginning basically to say "yeah, yeah, we're getting to Una, just hold your horses"
Overall I quite enjoyed this episode, though the protracted fight with Chapel/M'Benga didn't really do it for me.
<!-- episode "S02E02" 2023-06-23 -->
wait is that Mrs McMurray? was she also in S1 and I just completely missed it?
love a good courtroom episode, thats what i always say
<!-- episode "S02E03" 2023-06-30 -->
Ooh, love a good time travel episode
James T. Kirk!
Isnt this the timeframe that there should be sanctuary districts? I would love to finally see anything else connected to that DS9 arc
pick a more conspicuous car, james
So how did they manage to cross international borers
Holy shit.
smh, cant believe they retconned Khan to be from Toronto
that was very “this is not over” music at the end there
This was a truly phenomenal episode. Christina Chong and Paul Wesley were both fantastic.
<!-- episode "S02E04" 2023-07-06 -->
This was a thoroughly enjoyable, no-frills monster of the week episode. I loved it.
<!-- episode "S02E05" 2023-07-15 -->
how has anything near Vulcan not already been scanned into oblivion? werent the Vulcans canonically spacefaring for hundreds of years before first contact with earth
ooh this is very disconcerting
damn tprings dad is a pushover
Pike has an absurdly fancy bathroom
Spock and Chapel are way better than him and TPring (and Jess Bush is great), too bad theyre doomed (not that his relationship with TPring isnt also doomed)
<br>
This was a fun episode
<!-- episode "S02E06" 2023-07-20 -->
I would not have given a phaser to the person who cant trust what shes seeing regardless of whether that was caused by something else
aww, look at the gang getting together
This was a pretty good episode. As the weeks go by, I keep hoping that this one will be the Lower Decks crossover episode.
<!-- episode "S02E07" 2023-07-22 -->
\*chanting\* lower decks! lower decks!
the new animated version of the enterprise looks great
boims stop saying things, you're going to break the future
so we have quintotriticale, quadrotriticale, and now tritriticale
Is that the first reference to the Bell Riots outside of DS9?
lmao @ Mariner beings even more of a weirdo than Boimler
Domjot! this episode is as crammed full of references as a Lower Decks one
That was a excellent episode; Tawny Newsome and Jack Quaid were both fantastic
<!-- episode "S02E08" 2023-07-28 -->
Raktajino, lmao
Clint Howard!
This was a very good, very dark episode.
<!-- episode "S02E09" 2023-08-04 -->
Ill admit, going in, I am skeptical. The Short Trek in which Spock and Una break out into Gilbert and Sullivan was fun—but an entire episode of them singing?
The ADR when theyre singing does not seem great
How would an explosion propagate through the comms
Ayy, Carol Marcus mention!
Credit where credit is due, this episode swings _really_ hard for the fences. That said, this episode does not do it for me. I found it just… tolerable.
<!-- episode "S02E10" 2023-08-23 -->
It would be nice to be able to see anything in this episode. It is possible to light things such that everyone is visible and it still looks dark.
I quite like new Scotty so far.
Surely there are other survivors on the saucer section that they're about to obliterate.
I greatly enjoyed this episode, and that it ended on a cliffhanger in true Trek fashion (though who knows how long we'll have to wait for the conclusion).
<!-- episode "Season 2 Conclusion" 2023-08-23 -->
This whole season was extremely good—there was only one (1) episode that did not work for me. Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow was probably my favorite—though Those Old Scientists is a close runner-up.
SNW does a really good job of the episodic-style of Star Trek, and does a fair job of updating it so it doesn't feel out of place. It has a good balance of standalone stories and character development/plot arcs that continue through the season.
As with the first season, I have nothing but good things to say about it. I eagerly await its return.